Dear Home Secretary,
Re: Proposed new immigration removal centre for women in County Durham
We are writing to raise our serious concerns about the plans to open a new immigration removal centre (IRC) for women in County Durham, in Autumn this year.
We are MPs, councillors, faith leaders, people seeking asylum and refugees, charity and community group leaders, health workers, academics and university staff, and public figures raised or based in the North East of England. We care deeply about justice and social cohesion in our communities. As you will know, the site that your department is planning to use for this new IRC has a disturbing history. During the 1970s and 80s, hundreds of young men were physically and sexually abused by members of staff while held at Medomsley Detention Centre.
The re-opening of Medomsley as an IRC will mean that it continues to be a place of suffering. Research shows that the majority of women who are detained under immigration powers are survivors of serious human rights abuses, including torture, rape and trafficking. Locking these women up has a devastating effect on their mental health.
In 2015 the charity Women for Refugee Women conducted research with women in Yarl’s Wood, then the main IRC for women, which found that 40 per cent of the women they interviewed said they had self-harmed while in detention. In the same year, the Chief Inspector of Prisons called Yarl’s Wood ‘a place of national concern’.
It is also the case that the detention of women often serves no purpose. Most women in Yarl’s Wood were released not to be removed from the UK, but back into the community to continue with their immigration cases. Indeed, is it more straightforward and less expensive, as well as less traumatic, to allow people to resolve their immigration status while living in the community.
Following Stephen Shaw’s reviews of vulnerable people in detention in 2016 and 2018, the Home Office took important steps towards reducing the use of immigration detention. You will be aware that one of these steps was commissioning the ‘Action Access’ alternative to detention
scheme, based in Newcastle, which has supported women who would otherwise have been detained to resolve their immigration cases in the community.
In fact, over the past couple of years the number of women in immigration detention has fallen significantly, from more than 200 in September 2018 to just 27 in September 2020. The plans to open a new IRC for women appear to mark a worrying step away from this welcome reduction in the use of detention.
We are also concerned about the disregard shown for the local community in the development of these plans. As you will know, Homes England had planned to remove the buildings at the Medomsley Detention Centre site and to replace them with housing. The housing development proposed would have had provision of 20 per cent affordable housing, along with approximately £1m commuted funds for investment in the local community.
Indeed, building new homes on the Medomsley site would have meant investment in local health and education services, new landscaping for local people to enjoy and environmentally friendly management of the land over the coming decades. Yet, without any local consultation, these plans have now been cancelled.
The mental health impact of re-opening the Medomsley site on those abused at Medomsley Detention Centre also appears not to have been considered. Durham Police’s investigation into the abuse, Operation Seabrook, is ongoing, and to date over 1,800 men have come forward to give evidence. A key local question which comes up again and again is, ‘Why are the Home Office so keen on re-traumatising vulnerable men at a time when a positive use for the site had already been found?’
For all of the reasons above, we urge you to reconsider your decision. Please do not turn the Medomsley Detention Centre site into an immigration removal centre for women.
Yours sincerely,
Mary Kelly Foy, Member of Parliament for City of Durham
Ian Mearns, Member of Parliament for Gateshead
Kate Osborne, Member of Parliament for Jarrow
Emma Lewell-Buck, Member of Parliament for South Shields
Neil Tennant, Pet Shop Boys
Peter Flannery, Scriptwriter
Jamie Driscoll, Mayor, North of Tyne Combined Authority
Umme Imam, Executive Director, The Angelou Centre
Michael Fawole, Centre Director, North East Law Centre
Dr Mohamed Nasreldin, Director, North of England Refugee Service
Hannah Barnes, Director, West End Refugee Service
Dr Alessandra Mondin, LGBT Asylum Community Worker, Rainbow Home
Julian Prior, Chief Executive Officer, Action Foundation
Jennifer Laws, Campaigns Manager, North East Asylum Matters
Dr George Rae, Chair, British Medical Association North East Regional Council
Dr Bethan Roberts, Co-chair, Forensic and Secure Environments Committee, British Medical Association
Dr Rachael Pickering, Co-chair, Forensic and Secure Environments Committee, British Medical Association
Dr Michael Shaw, Deputy Chair, British Medical Association Northern Regional Consultant Committee
Dr Karen Horridge, Consultant Paediatrician (Disability), South Tyneside and Sunderland NHS Foundation Trust
Councillor Heather Liddle, Durham County Council
Councillor Maura McKeon, Durham County Council
Councillor Marilyn Charlton, Gateshead Council
Councillor Bala Nair, Stanley Town Council; BAME Officer, North Durham Constituency Labour Party
Rabbi Sybil Sheridan, Newcastle Reform Synagogue
Father Adrian Tuckwell, Episcopal Vicar for Caritas Hexham and Newcastle, Diocese of Hexham and Newcastle
Abolish Detention – Hassockfield, Campaigning group
Owain Gardner, No to Hassockfield Campaign
Julie Ward, No to Hassockfield Campaign
Owen Temple, No to Hassockfield Campaign
Suzanne Fletcher, No to Hassockfield Campaign
Alison Hiles, No to Hassockfield Campaign
Fiona Ranson, No to Hassockfield Campaign
Angela Hanson, No To Hassockfield Campaign
Rachel Cope-Thompson, Student, Durham University
Severin Baker, Student, Durham University
Mollie Brown, Chair, Durham People’s Assembly
Sunjeev Sahota, Author of The Year of the Runaways and Lecturer, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Anne Jenkins, Coordinator, Women’s Economic Imperative
Mrs Rachel Wing, Volunteer/Treasurer, Refugee and Asylum Project, Stockton on Tees
Professor Cheryl McEwan, Head-Elect of Department of Geography, Durham University
Professor John Nash, Head of Department of English Studies, Durham University
Professor Catherine Donovan, Head of Department of Sociology, Durham University
Rachel Meenan, Secretary, North East Against Racism
Michal Chantkowski, Member of the Race Equality Advisory Group, People’s Powerhouse; Secretary, The Sunderland Black and Minority Ethnic Network Limited (SBMEN)
Steve Newman, Secretary, Wearside Amnesty International Group
Tony Dowling, Chair, People’s Assembly North East
County Durham Unites
Canny Little Library Collective, Canny Little Library
Phil Watson, Chair, Diocese of Hexham and Newcastle Justice and Peace Co-ordinating Council
Catherine Ruth Jowett, Licenced Reader (Lay Minister), Church of England
Kieran Thompson, Head of Talent, Diversity, and Inclusion, Cundall Ltd
Elaine Malcolm, Solicitor, Slater and Gordon Lawyers
Dr. Christine Chettle, Research Co-ordinator and Networker (Grief, Loss and Trauma Recovery Project), The Stoplight Approach
Ines Cardoso, Curator
Sam Slatcher, Director of Citizen Songwriters, Citizen Songwriters
Dr Shereen Al-Khabouri, GP
Lya Vollering, ‘New Story’ Eco-Community Walled Garden, Minsteracres Retreat Centre
Sharyn Maxwell, Copy Editor
Ashley Brown, Committee Member, North East Regional Council, BMA
Professor Nayanika Mookherjee, Professor of Anthropology; Co-Founder of BAME Network, Durham University
Dr Noreen Masud, Early Career Fellow, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Professor Patricia Waugh, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Gillian Skinner, Associate Professor, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Fraser Riddell, Lecturer, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Marco Bernini, Assistant Professor in Cognitive Literary Studies, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Angela Woods, Associate Professor of Medical Humanities, Durham University
Dr Eleanor Spencer-Regan, Vice-Principal and Senior Tutor, St Chad’s College
Professor David Lawton, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Chris Vardy, Teaching Fellow, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr James Robinson, Assistant Professor, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Samuel Thomas, Associate Professor, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Professor Jane Macnaughton, Professor of Medical Humanities, Durham University
Dr Helen L Thompson, Postdoctoral Research Scientist, Department of Biosciences, Durham University
Grace Norman, Hatfield Development Officer, Durham University
Professor Sue Black, Professor of Computer Science and Technology Evangelist, Durham University
Dr Karen Milek, Associate Professor, Department of Archaeology, Durham University
Amy Cutts, Human Resources Administrator, Durham University
Donna Carr, Careers Adviser, Durham University
Dr Kris Kovarovic, Associate Professor, Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Lynn Gibson, Research Institute Manager, Durham Energy Institute, Durham University
Dr Alison Jobe, Assistant Professor, Department of Sociology, Durham University
Nicky Sawicki, Corporate Marketing Officer, Durham University
Dr Katherine Puddifoot, Assistant Professor, Department of Philosophy, Durham University
Laura Smith, Employer Services Manager, Durham University
Dr Julia Knapp, Assistant Professor, Department of Earth Sciences, Durham University
Laura Dorian, Senior Project Manager, Durham University
Dr Marzieh Kouhi Esfahani, Teaching Fellow, School of Government and International Affairs, Durham University
Dr Sui-Ting Kong, Assistant Professor in Social Work, Durham University
Dr Joanna Berry, Associate Professor in Entrepreneurship, Durham University
Adriana Salazar Méndez, Lead Business Analyst, Computing and Information Services, Durham University
Dr Geetanjali Gangoli, Associate Professor in Sociology; Co-Chair of BAME Network, Durham University
Dr Amitabh Trehan, Associate Professor, Department of Computer Science, Durham University
Professor Simone Abram, Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Dr Maja Kutlaca, Assistant Professor, Department of Psychology, Durham University
Beth Barnes, Teaching Fellow, Department of Engineering, Durham University
Elizabeth Gordon, Head of Collaboration Services, Durham University
Joanne Spence, Learning and Teaching Manager, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Sophie Clough, Postdoctoral Research Associate, Department of Biosciences, Durham University
Dr Liadi Mudashiru, Senior Regional Manager (Middle East and Africa), Durham University
Lucy Morris, Scholarship Officer, Durham University
Nicola Silcock, Assistant Manager (Learning and Teaching), Department of Philosophy, Durham University
Dr Megan Baker, Post Doctoral Research Associate, Department of Geography, Durham University
Roger Smith, Professor in Social Work, Durham University
Dr Michael Crawley, Assistant Professor, Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Pauline Dowson-Pounder, Partnerships Co-ordinator, Durham University Business School
Rachel Bickerdike, Enterprise Manager, Durham University
Professor Rachel Kendal, Professor in the Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Miss Ann Herzog, Employer Engagement Coordinator, Durham University
Dr Nikki D’Souza, Teaching Fellow, Department of Sociology and Criminology, Durham University
Alishya Dhir, PhD Researcher, Department of Sociology, Durham University
Dr Hannah Brown, Associate Professor of Anthropology, Durham University
Dr Paolo Fortis, Associate Professor, Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Helen Jackson, Work Experience Manager, Durham University
Dr Emma Short, Lecturer in Modern and Contemporary Literature, Durham University
Rosalind Jelfs, Information Services Manager, Durham University
Dr Jinrui Pan, Assistant Professor in Economics, Durham University
Dr Stephen Burrell, Assistant Professor (Research), Department of Sociology, Durham University
Kelly Brown, Learning and Teaching Administrator, Department of History, Durham University
Elkie Robinson, Finance Manager, Durham University
Lottie Ayres, Pharmacist and PhD research student, Department of Chemistry and Pharmacy, Durham University
Laura Todd, Vice Principal and Senior Tutor, College of St Hild and St Bede, Durham University
Dr Sally Street, Assistant Professor, Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Michelle Taylor, Senior Organisation Development Manager, Durham University
Simone Devine, Enquires Administrator, Durham University
Melanie Earnshaw, Equality, Diversity and Inclusion Officer, Durham University
Dr Donna Marie Brown, Associate Professor, Department of Sociology, Durham University
Leanne Britton, Enquiries Manager, Durham University
Dr Stephen Ashe, Teaching Fellow in Sociology, Durham University
Dr Julie Crane, Associate Professor, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Laura Bielby, Faculty Placement Manager, Durham University
Dr Sitna Quiroz, Assistant Professor in the Study of Religion, Durham University
Danielle Cameron, HR Team Leader, Durham University
Eloise Hepburn, Teaching and Learning Administrator, Durham University
Dr Alice Stefanelli, Lecturer in Mathematics, Durham University
Sabine Tenge-Heslop, Lecturer in German, Durham University
Janet Cummings, Administrator, Durham University
Dr Adam Talib, Associate Professor/Director of Studies in the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University
Professor Gerald Moore, Professor in French Philosophy and Digital Studies, Durham University
Dr Charlotte Branchu, Lecturer and Honorary Research Fellow, Department of Sociology, Durham University
Professor Ita Mac Carthy, Professor in the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University
Owen Walpole, CRM Campaigns Officer in the Recruitment and Admissions, Durham University
Professor Thomas Wynn, Professor in the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University
Dr Kerstin Oloff, Associate Professor in the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University
Dr Hazel Donkin, Assistant Professor (Teaching) in the School of Education, Durham University
Dr Edward G. J. Stevenson, Assistant Professor of Anthropology, Durham University
Dr Jesse Proudfoot, Assistant Professor, Department of Sociology, Durham University
Dr Jana Bacevic, Assistant Professor, Department of Sociology, Durham University
Dr Jennifer Terry, Associate Professor of English, Durham University
Dr Jonathan Saha, Associate Professor of History, University of Durham
Professor Abir Hamdar, Professor in the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University
Hayley Duffy, Accommodation and Allocations Manager, Durham University
Dr Sadaf Noor E Islam, Postdoctoral Researcher, Department of Anthropology, Durham University
Dr Stefanie Kappler, Associate Professor in Conflict Resolution and Peacebuilding, Durham University
Professor David Cowling, Professor of French, Durham University
Dr Sarah McLusky, Institute Manager, Durham University
Dr Harriet Evans Tang, Post Doctoral Research Associate in the Department of Archaeology, Durham University
Dr Zanna Clay, Associate Professor, Departments of Psychology, Durham University
Dr Roisín Laing, Leverhulme Early Career Fellow, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Sam Riviere, Assistant Professor, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Sarah Hickmott, Assistant Professor, School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University
Dr Hannah King, Assistant Professor Criminology, Durham University
Dr Lucy Szablewska, Researcher, Durham University
Dr Elizabeth Swann, Assistant Professor, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Heather Allinson, Technology Transfer Manager, Durham University
Dr Helen Charman, Teaching Fellow, Department of English Studies, Durham University
Dr Jane Wilcockson, Senior PostDoctoral Research Associate, Department of Sociology, Durham University
Nuria Polo-Pérez, Lecturer in the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, Durham University
Rowan Stace, Senior Research Administrator, Faculty of Arts and Humanities, Durham University
Dr Jessica Lehman, Assistant Professor of Geography, Durham University
F.W. Pritchard, Hon. Secretary in the Unions, Durham UCU
Dr Anna Rowlands, Associate Professor of Catholic Social Thought, University of Durham
Dr Elizabeth Powell, Assistant Professor (Research), Theology and Spirituality, Durham University
Dr Alex Fry, Postdoctoral Research Associate, Department of Theology and Religion, Durham University
Dr Kimberley Fowler, Lecturer in New Testament, Durham University
Sol Gamsu, Lecturer/Trade Unionist, Durham University/Durham UCU
Professor Gerard Loughlin, Professor of Christian Theology, Durham University
Professor Alec Ryrie, Professor of the History of Christianity, Durham University
Alex Rowe, PhD Candidate and Teaching Assistant, Department of Theology and Religion, Durham University
Professor Mike Higton, Professor of Theology and Ministry, Durham University
Professor Karen Kilby, Bede Professor of Catholic Theology, Durham University
Professor Simon Oliver, Professor of Divinity, Durham University
Rowan Stace, Senior Research Administrator in the Faculty of Arts and Humanities, Durham University
Mary Robson, Research Associate and Creative Facilitator, Durham University
Revd Professor David Wilkinson, Principal, St John’s College, Durham University
Dr Jessica Eastwood, Lecturer, Department of Theology and Religion, Durham University
Dr William Crozier, Lecturer, Department of Theology and Religion, Durham University
Eli Auslender, PhD Candidate, Department of Politics, University of York
Dr Julie Rugg, Senior Research Fellow, University of York
Jean Grugel, Professor of Development Politics, University of York
Dr Adam Stock, Senior Lecturer in English Literature, York St John University
Professor Kathryn Cassidy, Professor of Geography and Environmental Sciences, Northumbria University
Dr Peter J Forman, Lecturer in Human Geography, Northumbria University
Chiara Broglia, Student at Durham University
Emily Raikes, Student
Harley McCourt, Activist
Sally Capes, Volunteer, Mary Thompson Fund
Louise Maxwell, Head of Continuous Improvement
Alison Stancliffe, Global Issues Educator, Tyneside
Clare Brown, Volunteer, Canny Little Library
Danielle Baker, Student
Piers O’Connor, Resident
Johannes Kotzee, Resident
Natalie Keogh, Local resident
Caron Naude, Member of the community
Rosa Stourac McCreery, Local resident
Ruby Topping, Student, Durham University
Anna Hutchinson, Concerned local resident
John Lowe, Durham City resident, City of Durham Trust
Sherene Meir, Community Organiser
Lameck Sibanda, Protection seeker
Sarah Hopwood, Local campaigner
John Stenhouse, Retired HR practitioner
Laura Nicol, Resident
Judith McSwaine, Volunteer
Floor van der Hout, Activist
Sehrish Mushtaq, Protection seeker
Maria Luck, Westminster Researcher
Petra Todd, School student
Angela Tracy
George O’Donnell
Margaret O’Donnell
Elizabeth Millican, Student Support Administrator, student, mother
Jodie Brown, Collections Coordinator
Victoria Morgan, Education within Secure Estate
Caroline Todd, Lecturer in Art and Design (long time resident of Durham)
Eleanor Crane, Secondary Teacher
Sarah J Brown, Finance Officer
Dr Nicolete Burbach, Incoming Social and Environmental Justice Lead, Jesuit Centre
Leave a Reply
Your email is safe with us.
You must be logged in to post a comment.